Authentic Irish Coffee Recipe: The Perfect Winter Warmer

Ahoy, coffee lovers! Have you ever tasted a cocktail that combined the richness of black coffee with the warmth of whiskey and topped it off with the sweet delight of whipped cream? If not, then prepare to be excited because I have the perfect recipe for you. As a seasoned barista, I’m here to introduce you to The Toronto Star’s Irish Coffee Recipe that’s going to leave you craving for more.

Coffee is more than just another cup of joe; it’s an experience. And what better way to elevate that experience than by making a classic Irish coffee that will keep you warm on cold nights? The original Irish coffee was invented in 1943 and has been a go-to drink for coffee aficionados ever since.

The Toronto Star’s Irish Coffee Recipe is known for its simplicity, yet it offers a delicious blend of flavors that nothing else can come close to. Whether you’re looking to unwind after work or cozy up with loved ones on weekends, this recipe has got you covered. So, let’s dive in!

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

The Toronto Star's Irish Coffee
The Toronto Star’s Irish Coffee

Coffee lovers, have you ever tried a special twist on your favorite drink? Look no further than the Toronto Star’s Irish Coffee Recipe.

At first glance, it may seem like just another coffee recipe, but this is one that’s a cut above the rest. Here are just a few reasons why you’ll love this recipe:

Firstly, it’s the perfect choice for those chilly evenings when all you want to do is curl up and relax by the fireplace. The warm, soothing combination of hot coffee, brown sugar, and Irish whiskey will fill you with joy and ease any coldness in your bones.

Additionally, this recipe is perfect for when you’re hosting a party or having friends over. Impress them with a round of Irish Coffees and watch their faces light up with delight as they sip on the delicious drink. With just a few ingredients, you’ll be able to whip up this drink in no time.

Lastly, who doesn’t love a classic cocktail recipe? This drink has been around for ages and it’s still popular today because it’s simply that good. Whether you’re winding down from a long day or getting ready for a fun night out, an Irish Coffee is always a good idea.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for a simple yet delectable coffee recipe then the Toronto Star’s Irish Coffee Recipe is definitely worth giving a shot. Get cozy with a cup of this classic and I promise you won’t be disappointed!

Ingredient List

 Warm your soul this St. Patrick's Day with The Toronto Star's Irish Coffee!
Warm your soul this St. Patrick’s Day with The Toronto Star’s Irish Coffee!

For the Irish Coffee, you will need:

  • 1 cup hot coffee – The star of the show, it should be freshly brewed and hot.
  • 2oz Irish whiskey – Standard measure for a classic Irish coffee.
  • 1 to 2 tablespoons brown sugar, depending on how sweet you’d like your Irish Coffee to be.
  • Heavy cream – Whipped cream takes your coffee to the next level resulting in a tasty and indulgent treat.

Other variations to try:

If you’re feeling a bit daring, try some of these substitutions!

  • Bailey’s Irish Cream – It’s a variation that lends a unique flavor. You can replace the Irish whiskey with Bailey’s for a creamy, nutty indulgent-tasting twist.

  • Hot chocolate or black tea – For those who want to enjoy an Irish Coffee variation without having to consume alcohol, hot chocolate or black tea is your go-to.

To make it even more interesting, there are a wide range of other alcoholic adjustments available as well! Scratch your head and experiment away!

The Recipe How-To

 A simple but satisfying recipe that's perfect for coffee and whiskey lovers alike.
A simple but satisfying recipe that’s perfect for coffee and whiskey lovers alike.

Here are the steps to make The Toronto Star’s Irish Coffee Recipe:

Step 1: Gather the Ingredients

Before getting started, gather all the ingredients you will need. These include:

  • 6-8 ounces hot black coffee
  • 2 tablespoons brown sugar
  • 2 ounces Irish whiskey
  • Heavy cream, whipped

Step 2: Prepare the Coffee

Brew some hot and fresh coffee according to your liking. Ensure that it is quite strong so that it can hold its flavor against other ingredients.

Step 3: Add the sugar and whiskey

Add two tablespoons of brown sugar to the coffee while it’s still hot. Stir until it dissolves into the coffee. Next, add two ounces of Irish whiskey into the same cup, stirring well.

Step 4: Whipped Cream Topping

Finally, float a layer of heavy whipped cream on the surface of the coffee. The cream added should be slightly whipped rather than fully made and its taste should be such that it balances out with the sweetness of sugar and strongness of whiskey.

Serve your perfect cup of Irish Coffee immediately to enjoy its warmth and incredible flavors.

Substitutions and Variations

 With only five ingredients, this recipe is easy to make and perfect for impressing your guests.
With only five ingredients, this recipe is easy to make and perfect for impressing your guests.

If you’re feeling a little adventurous, try some of these substitutions and variations to put your own spin on the classic Irish Coffee recipe:

– Switch up the liquor: While Irish whiskey is the go-to for this recipe, you can also use other types of whiskey or liqueurs such as Baileys Irish Cream or Kahlúa. These variations will add a sweeter, creamier taste to your drink.

– Add flavorings: Play around with different flavorings like vanilla extract, cinnamon, or nutmeg for an extra burst of warmth and aroma. You can also try adding a dash of bitters for an herbal twist.

– Use coffee alternatives: If you’re not a fan of black coffee, try using hot chocolate or tea instead. You could even experiment with swapping in different blends of coffee beans to see how they affect the overall taste.

– Make it frozen: Blend all the ingredients together with some ice for a delicious frozen Irish coffee cocktail. This is a particularly refreshing option during the warm summer months.

– Skip the whipped cream: While traditional Irish Coffee is served with whipped cream on top, you can leave it off if you prefer. Alternatively, try using coconut cream or almond milk as a dairy-free alternative.

Remember, the possibilities are endless when it comes to making coffee cocktails! Don’t be afraid to get creative and try new things.

Serving and Pairing

 Get ready to taste the creamiest Irish Coffee that will leave you with a smile.
Get ready to taste the creamiest Irish Coffee that will leave you with a smile.

Now that you’ve made the perfect Irish coffee, it’s time to enjoy it! This classic drink is best served hot and accompanied by a few simple sides.

When it comes to pairing food with Irish coffee, don’t overthink it. The dark flavors of the coffee and whiskey pair well with something sweet like chocolate or pastries. Try pairing your Irish coffee with some freshly baked scones or a slice of rich chocolate cake.

For a lighter option, consider serving your Irish coffee with a side of fresh fruit. The acidity of the fruit will complement the richness of the drink.

In addition to food, consider serving your Irish coffee with a side of whipped cream on top. Heavy cream or whipped cream is the traditional topping for an Irish coffee and balances out the bitterness of the black coffee.

When it comes to presentation, serve your Irish coffee in a warmed glass mug or footed glass to keep it warm for longer. You can also add a sprinkle of cinnamon or nutmeg on top for an extra flavor boost.

So sit back, relax, and enjoy your delicious homemade Irish coffee. It’s perfect for those chilly winter nights or mornings when you need a little extra boost. Sláinte!

Make-Ahead, Storing and Reheating

 This recipe's secret ingredient? Brown sugar! It adds a rich, molasses-like depth that you won't find in any other Irish Coffee recipe.
This recipe’s secret ingredient? Brown sugar! It adds a rich, molasses-like depth that you won’t find in any other Irish Coffee recipe.

There’s nothing more satisfying than having a warm Irish coffee at home. But sometimes, we don’t have the time to freshly brew coffee and whip up ingredients in the morning. Worry not; our recipe allows you to prepare this delicious hot drink in advance and store it for later.

To make ahead, prepare the coffee, whiskey and brown sugar mixture and keep it refrigerated up to 2 days. To reheat, simply pour the mixture into a heatproof mug and microwave or reheat on the stove over medium heat until warmed through.

Avoid reheating whipped cream as it loses its texture when heated. Instead, keep it chilled separately and add it just before serving. You can also use canned whipped cream if you’re short on time.

Storing Irish coffee can be quite tricky because whipped cream doesn’t last long when exposed to air. If you want to store your Irish coffee in large batches, pour the coffee mixture into an airtight container without whipped cream and refrigerate. When serving, pour desired amount of coffee mixture into a mug, top with fresh whipped cream, and enjoy.

This drink is perfect for a make-ahead brunch party or when you want to step up your drinking game after work. Notes on preparing ahead make this recipe extra helpful for anyone who wants to enjoy this classic drink with minimal effort. With our recipe, everyone can enjoy an Irish coffee anytime they want!

Tips for Perfect Results

 Say sláinte as you cozy up with a cup of this comforting classic cocktail.
Say sláinte as you cozy up with a cup of this comforting classic cocktail.

To make the best Irish coffee, it is essential to follow a few tips that will give you a perfect blend of coffee, whiskey, and whipped cream. As a barista, I have developed some techniques that can be helpful for preparing an excellent Irish coffee.

Firstly, freshly brewed strong coffee is the essential ingredient in the recipe. Make sure you use high-quality beans and grind them right before brewing. This will ensure the coffee has a bold flavor profile to compliment the whiskey.

Secondly, when adding sugar to the drink, it’s best to go with brown sugar. It provides a richer taste and adds complexity to the recipe compared to white sugar.

Thirdly, choose a good quality Irish whiskey that has an excellent balance between alcohol and flavor. Jameson or Bushmills are perfect for this recipe. Remember not to pour too much whiskey as it can overpower the coffee.

Fourth on our list is the whipped cream; make sure it’s fresh with no added sugar or other flavors. Fill your shaker with heavy cream ice cubes, shake well until its thickened up and then spoon over your hot drink. To achieve perfection every time, try shaking only small amounts of heavy cream in your shaker instead of large portions.

Fifthly, temperature control is vital when making Irish coffee- make sure you serve it at hot temperatures all around from using pre-heated mugs to ensuring all ingredients are hot before adding them into your drink- this makes it more enjoyable!

Finally, don’t forget to enjoy your drink! Irish coffee should always be savored slowly like any other cocktail or drink with alcohol content. It’s a drink meant for relaxation after a long day while enjoying rich flavors of coffee and whiskey.

By following these tips for perfect results, you can make sure every cup of Irish Coffee becomes one that brings joy and satisfaction.


Now that you have all the details on how to make a delicious Toronto Star Irish Coffee, let’s dive into some of the FAQ’s that often arise when making this classic cocktail. Whether you’re wondering about substitutions, variations, or serving suggestions, I’ve got you covered with all the information you need for perfect results every time. So keep reading to find answers to some of the most commonly asked questions about this beloved drink!

How is the Irish coffee made?

If you’re looking to enjoy a classic Irish Coffee, then here’s how I’d recommend making it. First, pour some hot coffee into a pre-warmed glass, leaving a bit of space at the top. After that, add brown sugar to the coffee and give it a good stir until the sugar completely dissolves. Next, blend some Irish whiskey into the mix. Lastly, take some heavy cream and gently pour it over a spoon onto the top of the drink to create a whipped cream collar. And there you have it, a delicious Irish Coffee ready for sipping!

What was original Irish coffee made of?

According to the history of Irish coffee, the idea came from a chef named Joe Sheridan who added some whiskey to hot coffee to give warmth to the customers. This resulted in the creation of the original Irish coffee recipe consisting of only four simple ingredients: hot coffee, sugar, cream, and whiskey in a five-step process.

What is the best coffee to make Irish coffee?

When it comes to coffee, everyone has their own unique preference. From a light roast Colombian to a dark French roast, the options are endless. And when it comes to making a coffee cocktail, you have the freedom to choose any type of coffee you desire.

What kind of whiskey is used in Irish coffee?

When it comes to Irish Coffee, the Sexton Single Malt whiskey is a popular choice amongst bartenders due to its genuine and delightful taste. Crafted from malted barley and distilled thrice in copper pot stills, this whiskey is then matured in Oloroso sherry casks to obtain a fruity flavor that is irresistible.

Bottom Line

In conclusion, the Toronto Star’s Irish Coffee Recipe is the perfect way to treat yourself and your friends. This recipe offers an original Irish coffee made with hot coffee, sugar, and Irish whiskey that will warm you up on even the coldest days. It’s easy to make and can be customized to suit your preferences by substituting ingredients or adding variations such as frozen Irish coffee or hot chocolate.

This recipe brings together the best of both worlds – a delicious hot beverage and alcohol – in a unique way that is sure to impress. The addition of whipped cream and brown sugar makes it a sweeter treat that balances well with the strong flavor of the black coffee.

Whether you are hosting a book club meeting or having a cozy night in, this recipe is guaranteed to delight your guests. So why not whip up a batch today? You won’t regret trying out this classic cocktail recipe that has stood the test of time.

So grab your coffee beans, heavy cream, and Irish whiskey – it’s time to make the best Irish coffee recipe from Toronto Star!

The Toronto Star's Irish Coffee

The Toronto Star’s Irish Coffee Recipe

I clipped this back in the early 1980s from a Toronto Star article on St. Patricks Day, and just found it tonight! Talk about timing!
No ratings yet
Prep Time 2 mins
Cook Time 0 mins
Course Beverage
Cuisine Irish
Calories 246.6 kcal


  • 2 ounces Irish whiskey
  • 2 tablespoons brown sugar (or to taste)
  • black coffee (hot and strong)
  • whipped cream


  • In a pre-warmed stemmed heatproof glass (yes, you can also use a prewarmed coffee mug, but it doesn't look as good), pour in whisky, then add sugar, then pour in coffee up to within 1/2-inch of rim.
  • Stir well to dissolve sugar.
  • Fill to the brim with whipped cream.
  • Serve, enjoy, relax!

Add Your Own Notes


Serving: 85gCalories: 246.6kcalCarbohydrates: 27.1gSodium: 7.7mgSugar: 26.8g
Keyword < 15 Mins, Beginner Cook, Beverages, Canadian, Dessert, Easy, European, Healthy, Kosher, Low Cholesterol, Low Protein, No-Cook, St. Patrick's Day
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

Recommended Recipes Just For You

None found